Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Cross-Forest Migration and Exchange 2010 "hosting mode"

I'm consulting for a large company with 2 forests (Forest A and Forest B) running 7 domains - all Exchange 2003.

I am creating a new forest, Forest C.

All users, groups, computer objects and contacts are being migrated from all domains in Forest A and Forest B into a new domain in Forest C.

My customer wanted to know if it was possible to move the users mailboxes "into the cloud" during the migration a forth forest, Forest D by an Exchange hosting provider running Exchange 2010 "hosting mode".

Here is a copy of the response I received from Microsoft on the matter:

Hi Clint,

Thanks for your update.

So, here I would like to re-understand your concern: there are four forests A, B, C and D(D forest is installed with hosting mode Exchange 2010 ). You want to confirm that whether it is possible to migrate user accounts, groups, computer accounts and other Active Directory objects from forest A, B to forest C while migrating mailboxes to forest D. Please let me know if there is any misunderstanding.

If my understand is correct, I would like to let you know that it is not recommended migration because of the following reason:

1. If we migrate the mailbox and Active Directory account to different forest, we have to create linked mailboxes. However, Exchange 2010 which is installed in hosting mode don't support "resource forest". For example, based on the result of many tests, if we create a mailbox in forest D for the user in forest C, this user is not able to see others in Global Address List while others are able to see him/her in Global Address List.

2. Hosting mode Exchange server is designed for multi-tenant. It is designed for those companies and organizations which haven't Active Directory and Exchange. So if we migrate mailboxes to the forest which holds hosting mode Exchange server, I believe there will be a lot of unexpected issues and inconvenience.

For your reference, I would like to share the following article with you:

Multi-Tenant Support
http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff923272.aspx

Please feel free to let me know if you have any concerns. I'm looking forward to hearing from you.

Best regards,
Leo Qin
Partner Online Technical Community


Hope this sheds some light on the matter for anyone facing the same scenario.

4 comments:

  1. Hello Clint,

    This is Leo. Do you have MSN? my e-mail is v-tiqin@microsoft.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Leo,

    This is clint. My msn is clint@kbomb.com.au.

    I added you though

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Clint,

    I am facing the same challenge right now, I mean I have to migrate 3 differents companies (their own AD forest, domain, exchange) to my New server "private cloud" solution. My question is what's the best way to achieve this goal? specifically what's the best option to move user's mailbox content? using export/import .pst? move mailbox across forest?

    I would really appreciate any help regarding this big challenge for me..

    Thank you in advance

    Arnold.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice, thanks for the helpful information about how to migrated from all domains in Forest A and Forest B into a new domain in Forest C. I found the good utility ( http://www.lepide.com/exchangemigrator/cross-forest-migration.html ) which easily perform cross forest migration. This tool allows to migrate to-and-fro between exchange server and complete migration including all items of users' mailboxes and provide the facilitate to migrations of Intra-forest and cross forest exchange server.

    ReplyDelete